Concrete5 “Enterprise Ready”? Not entirely…

We’ve written a lot about Concrete5 in Head Energy’s blog, with significant effort spent on documenting our high level AWS architecture for a large Concrete5 Sites. However, going back one step more (and stepping over my hate for the phrase “enterprise ready”, which seems to be synonymous with “bloated, cryptic and slow as hell”), we’re forced to ask today: is Concrete5 really an “enterprise ready” system?

Our project, built on v5.6.1, probably has 50k+ lines of code these days, and one of the ever increasing worries during our development has been that of slow page loads. We’re seeing un-cached page load times creep up from their early renders of 1s-2s to a current average of 4s-6s, and it’s getting worse linearly with the complexity of the page. The linearity suggests we’re simply introducing a greater workload and have only ourselves to blame, but after just a few minutes of looking for high load anywhere in our architecture I was at a loss, until I did the bog standard check for database queries.

The number of queries Concrete5 generates when using it’s own API is utterly staggering a landing page deemed moderately complex generated precisely 6882 queries to render from start to finish.

The number of queries Concrete5 generates when using it’s own API is utterly staggering a landing page deemed moderately complex generated precisely 6882 queries to render from start to finish, and the agent wasn’t even logged in! This isn’t a problem on a developers machine, where the latency between their MySQL layer and the web server is effectively 0. When we add a 0.5ms latency (think AWS load balancers, traffic managers or just networking!) the delay from latency balloons to 3.441 seconds in additional page load time.

What’s worse is we’ve taken some significant steps to reduce the number of Page List blocks in use on Concrete5, simply because we already knew it was ridiculously heavy on the database with only a few dozen pages in play. We wrote an override which completed what Concrete5 was achieving in the Page List from hundreds of statements in just one (without permissions however, but more on that in a moment).

Finding out the number of database queries Concrete5 generates per page

Concrete5 comes packing the adodb abstraction layer, which has a nice inbuilt function to log all database queries into a table. To make use of it you’ll probably have to create the logging table manually (we did) the statement for which is:

CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS `adodb_logsql` (
  `created` datetime NOT NULL DEFAULT '0000-00-00 00:00:00',
  `sql0` varchar(250) NOT NULL DEFAULT '',
  `sql1` text NOT NULL,
  `params` text NOT NULL,
  `tracer` text NOT NULL,
  `timer` decimal(16,6) NOT NULL DEFAULT '0.000000'
)

Once created switching on the logging function within Concrete5 is as simple as calling

Database::setLogging(true);

You can use this around particular operations in your code, just to take a peek, or just as a quick solution throw it right at the bottom of:

concrete/core/libraries/database.php

Now, every time you reload a page in Concrete5, the adodb_logsql table will fill up with the queries generated to make that page load. We’ve confirmed our suspicions that the Page::getBy* methods are kicking out a significant chunk of our statements, and plan to remove as many of these as possible over the next few days in place of customized SQL.

Is Concrete5 Enterprise Ready?

If your environment is very cache friendly, or you don’t have too many pages (arbitrarily e.g. 250+), then yes you’ll love the entire journey without the need to get very technical. If this isn’t the case, then you’ll quickly need a set of proficient developers who are happy to replace chunks of Concrete5′s native functionality with more efficient alternative routines (namely less SQL statements!).

That said, we’re still hugely enamoured with our choice of platform, and do not believe any other system offers a better ratio of user friendliness, flexibility, scalability and out of the box CMS features, at least not yet.

, , , , ,

Follow Us

Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates.

2 Responses to “Concrete5 “Enterprise Ready”? Not entirely…”

  1. Dan February 26, 2013 at 11:05 am # Reply

    6k+ queries is frankly unacceptable, whilst the ultimate flexibility that developers are offered in concrete 5 is very appealing, that is simply far too high.

  2. Franz March 2, 2013 at 4:03 pm # Reply

    Thanks for taking the time to poke around with concrete5.

    You’re right that concrete5 uses quite a few database queries to render a page. It’s also true that if one is designing an application from scratch to serve one purpose, it’s quite easy to solve most problems in a handful of queries. As you know however, concrete5 provides a tremendous amount of flexibility right in the core. While I’m sure there will always be opportunities to clean up queries and the number of objects loaded, you’re always going to hit the database a lot when you have page,block area, and block level permissions that can each include multiple exceptions, timed releases, etc..

    Our experience has been that its more important to look at actual use instead of abstract terms and gut based rules. We see concrete5 being used in two very different fashions at the enterprise level. Sometimes organizations are building extranet/intranets for their staff, dealers or partners. These often require complex permissions and workflow, which concrete5 allows a product manager to do without touching code. These sites, even at the enterprise level, are usually serving tens of thousands offers, and can run just fine on a well provisioned web server.

    Other times organizations are building front end focused informational sites. These tend to be pretty flat in terms of interactivity and complex permissions. The benefit is from the ease of editing. What we do in those cases is run Varnish cache before concrete5, which makes the site faster than apache and static HTML files. I think you’ll find this to be much easier than gutting parts of the system on an as needed basis.

    Thanks again for the write up,

    Franz maruna, CEO concrete5

Leave a Reply